We Audited Motherlove's Amazon Listing: One of the Best-Rated Nipple Creams on Page 1

Watch the video

Video coming soon. Subscribe to our YouTube channel to get notified.

Why we audited Motherlove's Amazon listing

This is the first post in our Listing Audit series. Every few months, we pick a brand with a great product and a real business behind it. We audit the Amazon listing for its best seller, the same way we audit our own clients' listings. Then we show what we would fix first.

Motherlove makes one of the best-rated nipple creams on page one of Amazon, with 4.8 stars from more than 16,000 reviews. But Earth Mama sells about 7 times as many units, at about $1 less per ounce. Motherlove is resonating with moms, but the listing is missing important content that could help it win more customers. (Sales figures are SmartScout estimates from November 12, 2026. yourAMZ is not connected to Motherlove. This blog is for educational purposes only.)

Want us to look at your ad spend this closely? Book a free Advanced Advertising Audit. We only take three per month.

What Motherlove already gets right

A lot of the hard work is done. Here is what is working:

• Brand search. When someone searches "Motherlove," all 10 results in the first two rows are Motherlove products.
• Organic rank. The Nipple Cream shows up in the first row when shoppers search the root keyword, "nipple cream."
• Buy box. Motherlove sells the product itself, Amazon ships it (FBA), and there are no resellers on the listing.
• Reviews. 16,300 reviews at 4.8 stars.

These are the things that take years to build. The rest of this audit is about the page itself.

Does the listing have every part it should?

Almost. Every part of the listing is in place except one: a product video made by Motherlove. The A+ section also has room for one more module that sits empty.

Having every part filled in is step one. The bigger question is whether each part helps a mom choose Motherlove.

What does a mom see when she searches "nipple cream"?

She sees a grid of jars and tubes. She compares the pictures, rating, review count and prices, and she clicks one. Your search tile has a second or two to win that click.

Reviews: strong. 4.8 stars ties for the best rating on the page. Its 16,300 reviews rank fourth, behind Earth Mama and Lansinoh. That is a lot of trust.

Price: high, but that is OK. The jar that shows in search is the 1 oz, at $12.99 per ounce. Every other cream on the page costs $5.22 to $6.99 per ounce. A higher price can work when you have the best rating. But the page has to explain why it is worth more, and right now it does not.

Title: too short. The title is "Motherlove Nipple Cream (2 oz)." It uses 30 of the 75 characters you get. The line under it gets cut off at "for…" so the word "breastfeeding" never shows. Lansinoh's tile says "Safe for Breastfeeding Baby" in that same spot.

Main image: too small. The search tile crops off the white space, so it looks fine there. But on the product page, the top half of the main image is empty. The box and jar fill only the bottom 43%, so they look about half size, and even smaller on a phone. It also shows only the box and the jar, the same look as Earth Mama's tile

Coupons or promotions: none. Two tiles in the sponsored row carry a green badge, "Save 5%" and "Extra 25% off when you subscribe." Motherlove has no coupon and no Subscribe & Save deal on the tile. A badge stands out in a grid of look-alike jars and gets clicks. A Subscribe & Save deal also turns some moms into repeat buyers, and moms use nipple cream for months.

Are the six images selling their nipple cream?

Not yet. The images are where most shoppers decide: they sit above the fold, take up more of a phone screen than the bullets, and are faster to read than paragraphs. We score them against 11 things every strong listing covers. Some examples: who the product is for, the problem it solves, proof that it works, why it beats the others, and why it is worth the price.

Motherlove's listing fully covers 0 of the 11. Eight are partly there. Three are missing.

The biggest gaps:

• No mom, no baby, no problem. No image shows a mom nursing or pumping, and no baby appears anywhere. No image names the pain she is trying to fix: sore, cracked nipples in the first weeks.
• The proof is hidden. The awards (The Bump, BabyCenter), "clinically tested," the organic seals and the B Corp badge all live in the bullets. Fewer shoppers make it that far.
• Three images say nothing. Images 3, 4 and 5 are photos of a jar with no logo, color or text. They could belong to any brand.

The top competitors use their images to make their case. Earth Mama opens with "Why Earth Mama Organic Nipple Butter" and four reasons. Lansinoh opens with "#1 Recommended Nipple Cream by Doctors in the U.S.," backed by a survey.

Motherlove has strong proof of its own but isn't showing it.

The reviews are full of selling points the listing doesn't use

We read the 100 most recent and top reviews. Moms keep saying the same things, in their own words. Most of it never shows up on the listing.

Four things moms love that the listing leaves out:

1. "A little goes a long way." 22 of 100 reviewers say one jar lasts months. This is the answer to the higher price, and no image or bullet says it.
2. Smooth, not sticky. 27 of 100 reviewers talk about how it feels. The listing never describes the texture.
3. Better than lanolin. 32 reviewers say it beats the cream they used before. The listing says "free of lanolin" but never says why that is better.
4. Recommended by experts. 14 reviewers say a lactation consultant or the hospital told them about it. The listing never mentions it.

Your reviewers are telling you what to say. The listing just has to say it.

Gaps like this hide in ad accounts too, like spend on searches that never sell and proven winners that never get budget. See what yours is missing with a free audit.

Where is Motherlove's best proof hiding?

On its own website. Motherlove.com shows a row of six third-party seals: B Corp, Women Owned, CleanHub, USDA Organic, OTCO and Non-GMO Project. It shows real moms with their babies, next to their own words. None of this makes it onto Amazon.

The A+ section lower on the page could carry all of this. Right now it uses Amazon's plain built-in layouts with default text. Two problems stand out:

#1. The comparison chart is outdated. The A+ comparison chart shows a dash for Nipple Cream's price and a "Buying Options" button instead of "Add to Cart." The chart still points at an ASIN that is sold out or no longer showing on the parent listing. The reviews come from the parent, but the price and the cart button do not.

#2. No Motherlove video. The only video near the images is from an influencer, marked "Earns commissions." Earth Mama shows 18 videos. Lansinoh shows 6.

Is a listing redesign worth it?

For a product selling this much, yes. The math is simple.

Conversion rate is how many shoppers buy out of every 100 who visit the page. Let's assume this listing converts at 15%. That is 15 sales from every 100 visits. Now say an updated listing page pushed that to 17%. That is just 2 more sales from the same 100 visits with no change to ad spend, and it adds up fast:

• 2 more sales per 100 visits is about 13% more sales from the same ad spend.
• SmartScout estimates the Motherlove 2 oz jar brings in about $73,000 per month. 13% more is about $9,700 more per month, or about $117,000 per year.
• Those extra sales come from the same visitors. Ad spend stays the same.
• Say the margin after product cost and Amazon fees is 40% (an example, since we don't know Motherlove's). That is about $3,900 more profit per month, or about $47,000 per year.

That is one product. The same fix carries over to the 1 oz jar and the rest of the catalog.

In the months after a listing design project, our clients often see conversion rate rise 15 to 20%. Going from 15% to 17% is a 13% lift, a little under that range. This is a general estimate and we don't promise results. Conversion rate also depends on reviews, price, ads, seasonality and the quality of the listing before the redesign.

Here is what that looks like on a listing we designed for Bened Life's Cognition+. Each image has one job: what it does, proof, how to use it, what to expect, who it is for, and how to store it. Those are the same jobs Motherlove's images are not doing yet.

Scored on the same 11 checks, the full Bened Life listing covers all 11.

Here is what one client told us two weeks after their new listing went live:

Is your listing what's holding you back?

Maybe. Maybe not. The listing turns visits into sales. Your ads decide whether you get the right visitors, and whether those visits make you money or lose money. Before you fix one, it helps to know which one is the real problem.

That is what our free Advanced Advertising Audit is for. We go through your ad account and show you:

• Wasted spend on searches that never sell. That money can come back to you right away.
• Proven winners that are starved of budget, like searches that already sell at a profit but get almost nothing.
• Whether your listing is the bottleneck, so you know if a redesign should come first.

Insights are delivered within 24 hours. We only take three audits per month.

Book your free Advanced Advertising Audit